Our business hours are 7 days a week daily everyday. More about us: call ahead for take-out., winter: 11:00 - 9:00, free sesame seed crust on any pizza!, just ask!, chicken parimigiana w spaghetti or penne, heroes, ask about our, winter special, 2 plain pies, wed. only!!, 1.00 every other, 1 2 pie topping, pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, tomatoes, spinach, ricotta, peppers, jalapenos, onions, fresh garlic, black olives, fresh mushrooms, anchovies, pineapple, broccoli, artichoke, ham, bacon, eggplant, chicken, cutlet, grilled chicken, cheese pizza (one size 16 inch-8 slices), sicilian pizza (one size 9 slices), taco pizza (summer only), fountain drinks sm lg, lipton bristled tea, lipton brisk lemonade, 24oz bottled water, (pepsi, diet pepsi, root beer, sierra mist, orange slice) and (7 inch round 14x10 sheetcake). Our products and services include (ask about our daily specials), (fresh tomato, basil, garlic, mozzarella & extra virgin olive oil), (ham or spinach or sausage, ricotta & mozzarella), (mescaline greens, tomatoes, olives, onions, mushrooms, carrots), (pepperoni, ham, sausage, & meatballs), 2 liter bottles, add any topping, additional topping, appetizers, apple juice, ask about our, baked ziti, balsamic vinaigrette, bbq chicken, bbq chicken pizza, bbq chicken slice, beverages, bleu cheese, bruschetta, bruschetta (tomato, basil, garlic, mozzarella), buffalo chicken, buffalo chicken pizza, buffalo chicken pizza (spicy), buffalo chicken slice (spicy), buffalo wings w bleu cheese (6), buffalo wings w bleu cheese (8), calzones, calzones & specialty rolls, calzones & specialty rolls (eppi rolls), cannoli's, cappuccino's, latte's (hot or iced), cheese calzone (baked or fried w ricotta & mozzarella), cheese calzone (ricotta & mozzarella), cheese ravioli with marinara sauce (6), cheese ravioli with marinara sauce (8), cheese slice, chicken club (lettuce, omato, provolone), chicken club (lettuce, tomato, provolone), chicken club sandwich (lettuce, tomato, provolone), chicken eppi roll (chicken , marinara & mozzarella), chicken eppi roll (chicken, marinara & mozzarella), chicken fingers (5), chicken fingers (6), chicken marsala pizza, chicken marsala slice, chicken noodle, chicken parmigiana pizza, chicken parmigiana slice, chicken parmigiana w spaghetti or penne, chicken, eggplant or meatball, parmigiana, choice of dressing on the side:, choice of paul newman dressing on the side:, coffee, tea, coffee, tea & hot chocolate, cookies, desserts, dinners, eggplant parmigiana w spaghetti or penne, espresso (per shot), everything pie, everything pizza, fat free raspberry vinaigrette, fountain drinks, french fries, fried mozzarella sticks (6 sticks), fruit punch, fudge, garden salad (good for 2), garden salad (good for 2) ... (grilled chicken salad ), garden salad w grilled chicken, garden vegetable pizza, garlic bread, garlic bread (w cheese), garlic bread w cheese, garlic knots, gourmet pizza toppings, grandma pizza (thin crust sicilian fresh pesto & basil), grandma slice (thin crust sicilian fresh pesto & basil), hawaiian pizza (pineapple & sliced ham), hawaiian pizza (pineapple, ham - with or without sauce), hershey's ice cream (pints quarts ), hershey's ice cream (pints quarts), hot cappuccino, iced cappuccino, hot chocolate, hot pepper peppers (6), hot pepper poppers (6), ice cream, ice cream cakes for all occasions!, italian, italian hero, italian wedding, lasagna, late night hours, lentil, lipton brisk iced tea, margarita pizza (fresh mozzarella, tomato & basil), meat stromboli (ham, sausage, pepperoni), meat stromboli (ham, sausage, pepperoni, meatball), meatball parmigiana pizza, minestrone, mini cheese calzone (baked or fried), one topping 2nd topping and, open year round, orange slice, penne alla vodka, penne allan vodka, pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, tomatoes, spinach,, peppers & eggs, personal pizzas, pinwhe, pinwheel (ham & pepperoni or spinach), pizza & ice cream, pizza by the slice, pizza pies, ranch, raspberry vinaigrette, sausage & peppers, sausage, ham or spinach calzone or any stuffing, sausage, pepperoni & mozzarella eppi roll, school camp group discounts, shrimp or veal parmigiana, shrimp parmigiana (5) w spaghetti or penne, shrimp parmigiana (6) w spaghetti or penne, sicilian slice, side of marinar, side of marinara sauce, soup & salads, soup of the day (w garlic knot), spaghetti & meatballs (4 meatballs), spaghetti or penne with marinara sauce, spaghetti or penne with pesto sauce, specialty pizzas, summer: 11:00 - 12:00, super thin whole- wheat pizza (12 inch), super- thin sicilian pizza (one size 9 slices), the ice cream club, tiramisu, veal parmigiana w spaghetti or penne, vincenzo's meatzza pizza (pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatballs), we deliver, white pizza (ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan cheese) and zeppoli's - ice cream cakes. We prefer to use these brands: diet pepsi, hershey's ice cream, mug root beer, pepsi and sierra mist.

Visit Website: www.sagharborpizza.com

View Large Map    Get Directions

EE from Sagaponack, NY on Apr 13, 2014
Not just another pizzeria! This is the best one anywhere in Long Island as far as I am concerned. I say that because it's extremely cheap for starters, and then what you get is so much better than you would expect given the cost! The food is really top of the line. I've paid more at other restaurants and received less! Jamie V. from Wainscott, NY on Mar 14, 2014
I didn't think much of this place for a long time. Actually, I didn't think of it at all. It looks like nothing from the outside. But what's inside ... is some of the best pizza I've had in AGES. Check them out, you won't regret it. Robyn from Water Mill, NY on Oct 27, 2013
I must have bypassed this place dozens of times without looking twice at it, until I saw the reviews on this site. I was looking for a replacement for my old pizza restaurant, which was going south, so i checked them out. And now my problem is solved :) I wish that I'd known how great these guys were years ago! I'd probably have never patroned the other place. A Holloway from Southold, NY on Sep 28, 2012
Vincenzo’s Pizza is the best pizza jaunt in town – period! I’m summing up almost seven years of positive dining with them in one sentence, since there is nothing much I can say. I recommend them completely. Megan Early from Bay Point, NY on Sep 4, 2012
I like pizzerias as I really enjoy Italian food. However, finding a nice Italian place within our reach was a bit tricky, since we live in Bay Point. There is a great Italian place, though, in Sag Harbor which is really close. It is called Vincenzos Pizzeria and it features some of the most delicious pizza plates that I have ever tasted. We went there with my hubby so as to grab a bite and we were excited by the great variety of food options and the fine ingredients that they use. The salad that we ordered was freshly cut and seasoned with extra virgin olive oil and oregano, which was nice. The whole meal was delicious and we can not wait for our next visit at Vincenzo's Pizzeria. Ruby I. Fink from Wainscott, NY on Jul 14, 2012
This little place is quite a surprise since it doesn't look like much from the outside (or the inside really). It's a little shack, but the pizza is great, so don't be deceived by appearances! It's not necessarily the best gourmet I've ever tasted, but for the price it's top of the shelf. They use great ingredients, very fresh, and the perfect amount of cheese for a balanced flavor.

What really stands out about this establishment? It's the price and the taste - the value is super. You can't eat in here though, only take out, so don't plan on an eat-in meal. Stop in here for a quick slice which you can take with you or home or back to your hotel. Share Your Review

Do you have any experience using Vincenzos Pizzeria? If so, please rate your experience and let others hear about it using the form below.
 

Your Name:
City, State:	,
My Rating:
My Review:	Do not enter html
	Please enter this code into the box below.
Enter Code: