Harriet T. from
Islip Terrace, NY on Apr 27, 2014
OMG this place has the BEST PIZZA EVER for REAL
Tom A. Chang from
Deer Park, NY on Sep 7, 2013
The first time I came to Tony's, I ate inside. I didn't like it. i thought they were slow, and the food was good, but I didn't know if I wanted to come back. Then I thought of trying delivery, but they only do takeout. I came back and got takeout anyway, and I realized their food is actually really quite good. Since then I've gone back for takeout probably a half dozen times and been pretty happy with it.
Kay O. from
Bay Shore, NY on Jul 17, 2013
Really awesome pizza. There are a couple of downsides. Firstly, you can't order for delivery, and secondly, the service if you eat in is kind of fail at times. But that makes them ideal for takeout. I've never had a late order or an order that wasn't fresh and made exactly the way I wanted, and the food is absolutely outstanding. The prices are great, and they totally fill my "favorite pizza on LI" slot!
Share Your Review