Nicole A. Best from
West Islip, NY on Nov 7, 2013
This was one of the most wonderful places on the island. I attended a couple of parties here, and I will remember both of them forever. The food was divine, and the setting was something else--like a trip back in time. I am a big Fitzgerald fan, and the venue deserved its wonderful name.
Mary O. Helms from
Brightwaters, NY on Jan 6, 2013
It is so sad that this mansion closed down! I had several fond memories of the place. Whenever we wanted to entertain old friends, we also set up an evening out there. It was expensive, but for really important occasions--once in a lifetime types of occasions--it was the perfect, intimate place to be with loved ones. I hope that it opens again!
Peter A from
West Islip, NY on Aug 13, 2012
The Gatsby is an enchanting building and methinks its awesome. I’m going to try it out and then post another review about whether it is drab or fab! :-) Until then, stay tuned guys and try the Gatsby too. After all, what is the harm if you try the center once?
Patrick O. Flynn from
Brightwaters, NY on Jul 18, 2012
This was an intriguing old mansion which used to host parties and the like ... sadly I think it is closed now, though the building should still be there (drive by it and you'll be delighted by the architecture). As far as I can remember, I loved the house's interior, and the food served there was good, but many of the parties featured loud music, which could intrude on quieter more intimate gatherings. I hope that this place reopens eventually, maybe under new management that does a better job at scheduling different types of gatherings. It'd be nice to be able to visit again.
Share Your Review