I Clements from
Greenvale, NY on Mar 20, 2013
One of the best little Italian bakeries on Long Island, without a doubt. They have a big selection every day, but exactly what is available each day varies depending on their ingredient availability, what's been purchased before you arrive, etc. I kind of like the variety though; it forces me to try new things instead of just ordering my favorite thing over and over again.
Johnny West from
Greenvale, NY on Jul 18, 2012
Yum yum! I have to take some time to stop by here every week to pick up some treats for dessert. My family pesters me if I forget - everyone loves Italian treats baked fresh at the Old Fashioned Bakery.
EB from
Locust Valley, NY on Aug 3, 2012
Any time of the day or night I know Old Fashioned Bakery is open and ready to serve me. Although the name suggests they are only a bakery, one foot inside and you will see they offer so much more as well. When the aromas fill the air you will know you have made a visit you are soon to enjoy. I love this little place!
AT from
Locust Valley, NY on Aug 19, 2012
The name isn't very clear, but this is basically an Italian bakery, and carries all the delicious delicacies you'd expect from one. I really enjoy their cakes and coffee. I am also considering commissioning them to provide the baked goods for my wedding later this year.
Share Your Review