N Boyle from
Northport, NY on Sep 23, 2012
I love seafood, and like to treat myself and my wife about once a month to a night out on the town. We love going to Off The Hook Seafood Market & Grill.
I love their stuffed flounder with crab-meat, and my wife really likes the grilled shrimp scampi.
We usually start out with a drink and soup or salad, then maybe get a shrimp cocktail to share, then move on to our main entree. I can't say that I've ever had anything at Off The Hook Seafood Market & Grill that didn't taste fabulous.
The prices are a little higher then you might pay elsewhere, but the service, food, and atmosphere is well worth it. Definitely should go to Off The Hook Seafood Market & Grill as soon as you get a chance.
R Dalton from
Centerport, NY on Aug 17, 2012
We allowed ourselves one night to indulge on our Long Island vacation in a fine dining experience, and Off the Hook Seafood was it. You can't visit Long Island without being surrounded by the delicious smells of seafood wafting out of every restaurant after all. This place came highly recommended from Yelp reviews, so we gave it a try.
I ordered the tilapia and my wife got the scallops. Tilapia is usually a less expensive fish, and here you do pay top dollar for it. It was perfectly cooked though; not squishy and not slimy, and I am very picky about my fish. It also wasn't "fishy" tasting, which is also a big deal to me. So when I say I was happy with my fish, hopefully you understand my full meaning. It was outstanding, and my wife's grilled scallops were just as delectable. Give this place a try!
Share Your Review