I Bryant from
Shelter Island, NY on Jun 12, 2014
Love a nice sit-down meal by the bay? This restaurant is what you are looking for. They have some really outstanding lobster, and I just love the fact that you're allowed to bring whatever you want to drink and they don't get mad at you - saves money.
Wayne A from
East Hampton, NY on Mar 23, 2013
I love this place. It's right on the dock (as you'd expect), which is so much fun. Great atmosphere. The prices rock. Oh, and they actually sell fish and lobster; you can take it home and cook it yourself. The food they make here is outstanding though. I've heard people complain there is "too much bun" in their lobster rolls, but I like them that way. I don't like those little hot dog buns I'm used to getting on my lobster rolls in this town. These are far higher in quality. Their other dishes are awesome too. Oh, and just so you know, they don't do beverages. It is literally "bring your own."
One other thing that irritated me the first couple of times I was here; they don't always seat you right away. Sometimes they are busy handling fish market business. Go and find them and let them know you are there and want to sit, and they'll take care of you right away in most cases.
Share Your Review