I Shapiro from
Shelter Island Heights, NY on Aug 24, 2014
One thing I love about living around here is cheap pizza. You can grab a slice for just a couple of bucks, and it's huge and delicious. I recommend that you get it to go and take it home to eat because it's actually pretty messy.
O Locklear from
New Suffolk, NY on Feb 5, 2013
If you want pizza by the slice, Cheesy Charlie’s is a great stop. For $2.50, they don’t skimp. The pizza you get will be heavy with ingredients, and there are a lot of great choices. I actually had to eat mine using silverware, because it was threatening to fall apart when I tried to just pick it up and eat it. This, to me, was awesome. I like my pizza loaded! Staff were very friendly, and checked back with me several times to make sure that I was all right.
C Carver from
Cutchogue, NY on Oct 6, 2012
Cheesy Charlie provides you wonderful pizza that has overdoses on cheese. While its made me a lot fatter, I’m happier with the pizza too and shall visit as long as I crave pizzas, which I believe will be lifelong!
David Burns from
Southold, NY on Oct 10, 2012
Whether you want to go at a cosy little restaurant and grab a bite or order take out, Cheesy Charlie's Pizzeria is a great option if you live near Southold. The restaurant is a traditional Italian pizza place, with the cutest decoration and the friendliest staff. The food is wonderful, featuring tasty dishes of pasta and pizza, above all. The salads are abundantly rich and combine some great ingredients, veggies and herbs with extra virgin olive oil and other seasonings. The prices a re great, really affordable to anyone. I love eating lasagna and the most refreshing ice cream that I have ever tasted in my life. It is strawberry flavoured and it has got little chocolate chips inside, just to add a crunch.
Share Your Review
Report incorrect info
